Successive fraction changes are multiplicative. A fraction of a remainder uses a new reference amount, so translating the wording accurately matters more than the arithmetic itself.
Model what remains
If fraction a of a quantity is removed, fraction remains. Removing fraction of that remainder leaves of the original quantity. The overall removed fraction is
The overlap term ab explains why simply adding a and overstates the removal: the second removal is applied to an already reduced amount. This formula assumes the fractions describe successive removals, normally with values between 0 and 1.
Example: determine the original amount
A store sells of its notebooks in the morning and of the remainder in the afternoon. It then has 75 notebooks. How many did it have initially?
The retained fractions are and so of the original remains. If the original count is N, then giving
Check the story: the morning sale removes 80, leaving 120; the afternoon sale removes 45, leaving 75. These whole-number counts confirm that the result fits the setting.
The afternoon sale is of 120, which is of the original 200. The same event can be expressed by different fractions depending on the reference whole.
Equal-length bars represent the original notebook supply. The morning leaves ; keeping of that remainder leaves of the original, which equals 75 notebooks.
Describe this figure
Equal-length bars represent the original notebook supply. The morning leaves 3/5; keeping 5/8 of that remainder leaves 3/8 of the original, which equals 75 notebooks.
Example: a replacement changes the structure
A container holds 60 liters of juice. One third is removed, then 12 liters are added. Finally, one fourth of the resulting amount is removed. What remains?
After the first step, liters remain. Adding 12 produces 52. The final retained amount is liters.
You cannot describe the whole process by multiplying only retained fractions, because the fixed addition interrupts pure scaling. The correct expression is Parentheses identify the amount to which the last fraction applies.
Working backward from 39 would reverse the operations in reverse order: divide by subtract 12, then divide by
Compare same-base and changing-base language
If one third and one fourth of the original amount are removed in disjoint portions, the retained fraction is If one fourth of the remainder is removed after the first removal, the retained fraction is
The difference is not an exception to a rule. It comes from two different mathematical models. Circle or restate the base quantity each time the wording changes.
Successive removals commute, but intermediate amounts differ
If two removals are pure fractions of the current remainder, their final retained fraction is Multiplication commutes, so reversing their order gives the same final fraction. For example, keeping and then has the same final effect as keeping and then
The actual number removed at each stage changes, however. Starting with 200, removing first removes 80, then removing of 120 removes 45. Reversing the order removes 75 first and then 50. Both processes remove 125 in total and leave 75, but the stage-by-stage accounting differs.
This order independence does not survive every variation. A fixed addition between removals, such as adding 12 liters, is affected by the later retained fraction. Therefore do not rearrange a mixed sequence of fractional and fixed changes merely because multiplication itself is commutative. Preserve the story's operation order unless you have proved the rearrangement valid.
Try it yourself
After using one fifth of a supply and then one third of the remainder, 48 units remain. Find the original supply and the total fraction used.
Answer: The retained fraction is The original is The fraction used is Checking: use 18 first, then 24, leaving 48.
What to remember
Successive retained fractions multiply; disjoint fractions of one original whole add. Fixed additions or subtractions must appear at their actual stage. Verify a backward solution by replaying the complete story forward.