Combined-rate questions become manageable when you define the quantity changing: a gap, a distance, or the unfinished portion of a job. Rates can then be added or subtracted according to their effect on that quantity.
Relative speed describes the changing gap
If two objects move toward each other at speeds and their separation shrinks at If they move in the same direction, with the faster object behind, the gap shrinks at These statements assume constant speeds measured in the same units.
Rather than memorize which operation belongs to a keyword, imagine one minute of motion. Which movements reduce the gap? Which increase it? This reasoning also handles objects moving apart and objects that never catch one another.
Example: a delayed departure
A delivery truck leaves at 8 a.m. traveling at 45 miles per hour. A second truck leaves the same place at 9 a.m. traveling at 60 miles per hour along the same route. When does the second truck catch the first?
At 9 a.m., the first truck has a 45-mile lead. The second gains miles each hour, so it needs hours after its departure. It catches the first at noon.
To check with equal positions, let be hours after 9 a.m. The trucks have traveled and miles. Equating them gives hence Both have then traveled 180 miles. The first truck's travel time is 4 hours, while the second's is 3; confusing those clocks changes the answer.
First truck
Second truck
The first truck follows distance 45t plus 45; the second follows 60t. Their lines meet at time 3 and distance 180.
Using hours after 9 a.m., the trucks meet at 180 miles after 3 hours. The first truck starts this clock 45 miles ahead.
Describe this figure
The first truck follows distance 45t plus 45; the second follows 60t. Their lines meet at time 3 and distance 180.
Curves: First truck; Second truck.
Marked points: Head start: filled marker at (0, 45); Catch-up: filled marker at (3, 180).
Work rates are reciprocals of completion times
If a machine completes one job in hours, its rate is job per hour. Two independent machines with solo times and have combined rate Their joint completion time is
The formula follows from rate times time equals one job. It is useful only when both rates are positive and constant and the machines work simultaneously throughout the job. Deriving the rate equation is safer when the story has stages or opposing effects.
Example: find an unknown worker's rate
One worker can complete a task in 12 hours. Together with a second worker, the task takes 4 hours. Their combined rate is task per hour. Subtract the known contribution:
The second worker therefore needs 6 hours alone. Subtracting the times, would not isolate a rate. The check confirms that the two contributions produce the stated joint time.
Opposing rates and staged work
A pipe fills a tank in 5 hours while a drain empties a full tank in 20 hours. If their rates remain constant, the net filling rate is tank per hour. An initially empty tank fills in hours, or 6 hours 40 minutes. The drain makes the filling slower than 5 hours.
If a machine works alone before another joins, calculate the completed fraction first, subtract it from one, and use the joint rate only for the remaining fraction. If the net rate is zero or negative, an initially empty tank will not fill under that model; a negative computed “completion time” is not a valid physical answer.
Try it yourself
Machine A finishes a job in 10 hours. Machine B finishes it in 15 hours. A works alone for 2 hours, then B joins. How long does the entire job take?
Answer: A completes leaving The joint rate is job per hour. The remaining time is hours. Total time is 6.8 hours, or 6 hours 48 minutes.
What to remember
Use a common clock and compatible units. Add contributions toward the same goal, subtract opposing contributions, and separate stages whenever the active rates change.