Rationality is an exact property, not a statement about how many digits a calculator displays. Roots provide important examples of both rational and irrational numbers, so simplify before classifying.
What rational means
A rational number is a quotient of integers with nonzero denominator. Its decimal expansion terminates or eventually repeats. An irrational number has a decimal that neither terminates nor eventually repeats.
Thus and are rational, while and are irrational. A finite decimal approximation to an irrational number is itself rational: 1.414 is rational even though it approximates
Do not confuse a number with its displayed approximation. Exact classification requires information beyond a few digits.
Roots and principal values
For is the nonnegative number whose square is a. Therefore If replacing that expression with gives the wrong sign.
Odd roots preserve sign: Even roots of negative numbers are not real. The equation has two real solutions, but the expression equals 4 alone.
Example: simplify before classifying
Consider which is rational. Next, is irrational. The second radical has a perfect-square factor, but a non-square factor remains.
For a positive integer's square root to be an integer, every exponent in its prime factorization must be even. The number has an odd exponent on 2, so its square root is irrational. For a cube root to be an integer, all prime exponents must be multiples of 3.
These tests concern integer radicands. For rational radicands, reduce the fraction and examine numerator and denominator separately.
Example: sums can behave unexpectedly
The sum of two irrational numbers need not be irrational. For instance, Their product can also be rational:
However, adding a rational number to an irrational number always gives an irrational result. If were rational with rational, subtracting would make rational, a contradiction. Multiplying an irrational number by a nonzero rational also stays irrational. The nonzero condition matters because zero times any real number is zero.
These arguments explain why a few examples cannot justify a blanket claim about irrational arithmetic.
Bound a root exactly
To compare with 7.1, square both positive numbers. Since we have The positivity matters: squaring is increasing on nonnegative values, but not across all real numbers.
Similarly, so This exact interval may be more useful than a rounded calculator answer.
The square root of 50 lies above 7 and below 7.1. The comparison follows from .
Describe this figure
- √50: 7.0710678118654755
Why a nonsquare integer cannot have a rational square root
Suppose a positive integer N has a rational square root written in lowest terms with positive integers a and . Then If had a prime factor , the right side would be divisible by forcing a to contain as well. That would contradict a and being relatively prime. Therefore so the rational square root must actually be an integer.
This argument explains the rule for integer radicands: their square roots are either integers or irrational numbers, never noninteger rational numbers. For example, cannot secretly be a fraction such as since 18 is not a perfect square, its root is irrational.
The integer-radicand hypothesis is important. The number is a noninteger rational root of a noninteger rational input. Always identify the domain to which a theorem or shortcut applies before extending it to a new form.
Try it yourself
Is rational? Is rational? Simplify for unrestricted real .
Answer: The product is rational. The sum is irrational because adding a rational cannot make an irrational rational. The final expression is which accounts for either sign of
What to remember
Simplify exact forms, distinguish a radical from an equation's solutions, and retain absolute values. Rationality claims need a valid rule or argument, not a finite decimal display.